2027 protest sign-ups are open. Get ahead of the deadline.Estimate your savings →

Computer-Assisted Mass Appraisal (CAMA): How Texas CADs Value Homes
General Info

Computer-Assisted Mass Appraisal (CAMA): How Texas CADs Value Homes

Computer-Assisted Mass Appraisal (CAMA): How Texas CADs Value Homes

Quick answer: Computer-assisted mass appraisal (CAMA) is the software and statistical modeling Texas appraisal districts use to value every property in a county at once. The model takes the characteristics in your property record (size, age, quality, location), applies values learned from local sales and building costs, and produces your market value as of January 1.

Your appraisal district doesn't send an appraiser through your house before it sets your value. It runs your property record through a model. Knowing how that model works tells you where it goes wrong and what evidence fixes it in a protest.

What Is Computer-Assisted Mass Appraisal?

Mass appraisal means valuing a group of properties as of a given date using common data, standardized methods and statistical testing. Computer-assisted means the work is done in software that stores every property record, every sale and every model, and recalculates values for the whole county.

Texas law requires all taxable property to be appraised at market value as of January 1 (Tax Code 23.01). The same section says that when an appraisal district uses mass appraisal, its standards must comply with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), and that similar properties must be appraised with similar methods. It also says each property must be appraised based on the individual characteristics that affect its value. That last requirement is where homeowners have leverage: a model built for a neighborhood still has to be right for your house.

Mass appraisal (CAMA) Individual (fee) appraisal
Used by County appraisal districts Lenders, buyers, estates, protest evidence
Properties valued Every property in the county One property
Inspection Usually exterior, aerial or records only Usually inside and out
Valuation date January 1 Date of inspection
Accuracy measured by Ratio studies across groups of properties The appraiser's support for one value

How a Texas Appraisal District Builds a CAMA Value

Tax Code Section 25.18 lists the reappraisal steps each district's plan must cover at least once every three years. They are, in practice, the steps of a CAMA cycle:

  1. Identify properties through inspections, deeds, aerial photos, surveys and maps.
  2. Update characteristics in each property record (square footage, additions, pools, condition).
  3. Define market areas, usually neighborhoods of similar homes.
  4. Identify what drives value in each market area: location, size, age, condition, and legal or economic factors.
  5. Build a model that measures what each characteristic contributes to value in that market area.
  6. Apply the model to every property's characteristics.
  7. Review the results to set final values.

The plan doesn't stop a district from appraising property as often as needed. Most large urban districts revalue residential neighborhoods every year based on the latest sales.

What Data Goes Into a CAMA Model?

Input Examples Where errors come from
Property characteristics Living area, lot size, year built, bedrooms, bathrooms, pool, garage, stories Permits not recorded, old sketches, assumptions from aerial images
Quality and condition ratings Construction class, condition or "effective age" Rarely updated without an inspection; can't see interior wear
Neighborhood and location Neighborhood code, school district, flood zone, backing to a busy road Neighborhood codes that lump different streets or subdivisions together
Sales Prices of homes that sold near January 1 Texas doesn't require sale prices to be disclosed, so the district works from the sales it can collect
Cost data Cost to build the home new, minus depreciation Cost tables that don't reflect your home's actual wear or obsolescence
Income data (rentals, commercial) Market rents, vacancy, expenses, cap rates Market-wide assumptions that don't match your property's leases

The Three Approaches Inside the Model

Appraisal districts can use any of the three standard approaches, and the Tax Code sets ground rules for each:

  • Sales comparison (Tax Code 23.013): Comparable sales must be adjusted to your property. For residential property in a county with more than 150,000 people, a sale must be within 36 months of January 1 to count as comparable. Elsewhere the general window is 24 months unless there aren't enough sales.
  • Cost (Tax Code 23.011): The district must use cost data from generally accepted sources, adjust for physical, functional and economic obsolescence, and make the cost data available to the public on request.
  • Income (Tax Code 23.012): Used mainly for rental and commercial property, based on comparable rents and operating expenses.

For most homes, the model blends these: a land value for the lot, a cost-based value for the house adjusted by age and condition, and a neighborhood factor calibrated so the results line up with recent sales.

A Simplified Example

This is an illustration of the structure, not any district's actual schedule:

Step Calculation Value
Land value Neighborhood lot value $90,000
House replacement cost 2,500 sq ft x $160 per sq ft (quality class rate) $400,000
Depreciation 15% for age and condition -$60,000
Neighborhood market adjustment House value x 1.05 to match recent sales +$17,000
Model market value $447,000

Now suppose the record says 2,800 square feet instead of 2,500. The house cost becomes $448,000, and after the same depreciation and neighborhood factor the value rises to about $490,000. One wrong number added roughly $43,000 of value without anyone noticing. Wrong condition or quality ratings work the same way.

Are County Appraisals Accurate?

Two state programs check appraisal districts:

  • School District Property Value Study: The Texas Comptroller estimates the taxable value in every school district at least once every two years (Government Code 403.302) and compares it with the appraisal district's values.
  • Methods and Assistance Program (MAP): The Comptroller reviews each appraisal district's governance, taxpayer assistance, operating procedures and appraisal standards at least once every two years (Tax Code 5.102).

These reviews measure accuracy across groups of properties. A district can pass while many individual homes are valued too high, because mass appraisal accuracy is about the middle of the distribution. Homes with problems the model can't see are the ones most likely to end up on the high side:

  • foundation, roof, plumbing or drainage problems
  • original or dated kitchens and bathrooms
  • location drawbacks (backing to a highway, commercial use or power lines)
  • flood history or ongoing damage
  • record errors in size, features or quality class
  • a recent purchase for less than the district's value

How to Challenge a CAMA Value

Texas law gives every property owner the right to protest. Here is how to attack a mass appraisal value where it is weakest:

  1. Check your property record. Look up your account on your appraisal district's website. Compare square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms, pool, garage, year built and condition with reality.
  2. Request the district's evidence. After you file, you're entitled on request, at no charge, to the data, schedules, formulas and other information the district will use at your hearing (Tax Code 41.461).
  3. Gather better comparable sales. Find sales of homes that are actually similar to yours (size, age, condition, location) close to January 1. See how comparable properties lower your taxes.
  4. Show what the model can't see. Photos, contractor estimates, inspection reports and insurance claims.
  5. Make an unequal appraisal argument. You win an equity protest unless the district shows your value is at or below the median appraised value of a reasonable number of comparable properties, appropriately adjusted (Tax Code 41.43). Because CAMA values every home in your neighborhood, its own numbers often supply this evidence.
  6. File by the deadline. May 15 or 30 days after your notice is mailed, whichever is later. In 2027, May 15 is a Saturday, so the deadline is Monday, May 17, 2027.

For the full process, read our Texas property tax protest guide and what to expect at an ARB hearing. To understand the numbers on your notice, see market value vs appraised value, and for how the value becomes a bill, see how Texas property taxes work.

Sources

Let Us Check the Model for You

Ballard Property Tax Protest reviews your property record, pulls the appraisal district's evidence and runs our own valuation to find where the mass appraisal got your home wrong. We file the protest and represent you at every step. There's no upfront cost: you pay nothing unless we lower your taxes.

Sign up in a few minutes

Matthew Ballard
Matthew Ballard

Licensed Property Tax Consultant - TDLR #12593

Matthew Ballard is the founder of Ballard Property Tax Protest and has helped thousands of Texas homeowners reduce their property tax bills. He specializes in residential property tax protests across 18 Texas counties.

Frequently Asked Questions

DO YOU WANT TO PAY LESS IN PROPERTY TAXES?

We will help lower your property taxes

START NOW